From: Gurvinder Singh < >

Comment: The Muslims led by Jinnah demanded partition by threatening for a civil war; and also under DIRECT Action began killing Hindus in large numbers. The Hindus, hypnotized by MK Gandhi, agreed unwillingly. – Suresh Vyas)

The Great Game 200813 - Why Britain partitioned India - GW

Rich in every aspect, India is a land that has always been coveted by every power and wealth hungry empire and despot. Empires came and went plundering what they could, but it was the wily British who institutionalised it for exploitation.
It was the ‘Jewel in the crown’ of the British Empire, and every effort was made to retain, expand its hold on India.
The Great Game nowadays means something else today but in 1830 it was the rivalry between Russia and the British for control of all lands that could impact British trade
In 1830 the Muslim Ottoman Empire was visibly in terminal decline and the Russian Empire was in ascendant. The British feared the invasion of India by Russia and the loss of its lucrative trade,

The British lost the 4 major wars it fought with the Sikhs and the Afghanistan and eventually Afghanistan became a buffer state between the two empires.

Compelled by the Americans as per the Atlantic Charter a reluctant Britain had to give up its colonies and set the lands free after the end of the second World War.
Britain now fretted that if they vacated India, because nothing could then stop a victorious and strong Russia confident after its achievements in World War II from simply marching into India.

Britain wanted to retain bases with troops and equipment in India to prevent such an eventuality. Both Nehru and Gandhi flatly turned that request down.

On the other hand Muhammad Ali Jinnah an astute man with a much better understanding of geopolitics readily accepted the request unconditionally.
He offered the British ‘Carte blanche‘ unconditional support and bases if they appointed him the first Prime Minister of independent India

There was however, a small problem, Jinnah’s voice had almost no say in the Congress party. The problem was easily solved, partition India into a Hindu majority Secular India and a Muslim majority Pakistan and appoint Jinnah the Prime Minister of Pakistan. Pakistan is the area that was contiguous with Afghanistan and where Britain wanted to have bases and troops, thus create an openly pro British buffer state.

The die was cast, now to implant the plan. The British government had given a mandate to Mountbatten to grant India independence by July 1948.

Suddenly the plan was in danger. British intelligence had reliable information that Muhammad Ali Jinnah was suffering from tuberculosis and unlikely to survive another year.

Then there was the question, ‘what if the people of India and Pakistan decide to reunite?’ After all barring the occasional riot the people of all religions and communities within British India lived in relative harmony.

So not only was partition essential to post independence British plans but to do so in such a manner that they would remain bitterly divided for a long time.

The demarcation of the boundary between India and Pakistan was given to two teams of eminent lawyers uninformed, unadvised and unsuitable for the great task as boundary commissions. The notorious and ill fated demarcated line came to be known as the Radcliffe line.

Sir Cyril Radcliffe

Sir. Cyril Radcliffe

Sir. Cyril Radcliffe an English lawyer was summoned and assigned the job of trisecting most of India. He was appointed chairman of the two boundary commissions (One for Bengal and one for Panjab).

It is shocking to know, that Radcliffe had never visited India earlier, never read about or studied India until he was assigned the task. He was given just 5 weeks to complete the assignment. Arriving in India on July 8th 1947 he spent two weeks in bed recovering from ‘Delhi Belly'( a bad case of dysentery).

Radcliffe merely rubber stamped a plan that had been given to him by British authorities. We shall never know for certain, because Radcliffe destroyed all papers and records related with the decision of partition and he never spoke about it for the rest of his life.


Lord Louis Mountbatten and his wife Edwina Mountbatten with Jinnah - 1947 - 10

L to R – Louis Mountbatten, Jinnah and Edwina Mountbatten

Independence was granted at midnight on 15th August 1947. Then the exact map of Partition of India was announced on 17th August 1947.

India had been partitioned into 626 parts. India, East Pakistan, West Pakistan and 623 independent kingdoms. It was a disaster for the Indians.

Many Indians found themselves on the wrong side of the boundary and now prey to violent gangs intent on spreading terror, looting, raping and destroying.

Mountbatten who had promised law and order in the transition was inactive and silent. He let India burn, which many suspect was deliberate or gross incompetence.
Nehru and Jinnah busy in strutting into their new offices are also culpable for their neglect in their duty.

It seems evident, that the wily British had deliberately created a mess. They had the mischievous intent, to create enough long lasting problems in the Indian sub-continent to pave the way for Britain’s return to rule and dominate India once again sometime in the future.

Many people like to believe independence is mainly because of the trio of Gandhi ji and Nehru and Jinnah that got India and Pakistan freedom. Though this opinion is widespread it is grossly untrue.

It disrespects the blood, sweat and tears contributed by countless Indians, and even some Britishers and foreigners. The role of America was key.

Though Louis Mountbatten the Viceroy of India had time till June 1948 to complete the partition and grant India freedom, he used a butcher’s knife to tear out the soul of a people bound by centuries old shared culture and history.

Unclassified Russian documents reveal that Russia never had plans to invade India.

Pakistan by becoming a key partner of the Americans and British, evolved into a footstool for any power that would pay it mercenary fees and give it international support for all its mischief and terrorist activities.

Pakistan never learnt to exercise independence and remains independent only in name. Pakistan is now a failed Pariah state dependent only on a Communist China which is slowly sucking out whatever vitality is left.


Written and Posted: Aug 2020 ~ Gurvinder Singh – to earmark Indian Independence Day 15 August
You can also read the article and post a comment at: Blog – Blogspot

Engage – Articles – Website
Facebook – Twitter – linkedin – Instagram – SoundCloud – GDN Life –
South Asia Analysis Group – SikhNet

Ref: G0626

Interesting links.
Line of division – REAL AND IMAGINED ~ Kuldip Nayar
The Jewel in the Crown (TV series) – Wikipedia
The Great Game – Wikipedia
Why the British left India? – Guru Wonder
The Great Game Replayed – Indian Ambassador KC Singh

It was clear that a strong non aligned India had to be contained and what better than to give it a permanent headache in the form of Pakistan and 526 independent kingdoms. As Churchill hoped, that in a few decades, Indians would be begging the British to return and once again take charge of India.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s